Electric Chian Hoist vs. Electric Wire Rope Hoist | Similarity & Difference

Electric chain Hoist v.s electric wire rope hoist, which electric hoist is right for you? Check electric chain hoist & wire rope hoist benifits to select the right electric hoist for your application?

Similarity of chain hoists & rope hoist

Both an electric chain hoist and an electric wire rope hoist are heavy-duty equipment that use electricity to raise objects that are heavier than human strength. The application also encompasses situations where the lifting height is greater or where it is required often. Both electric chain hoists and wire rope hoists have seen substantial improvements in performance thanks to modern design and innovative mechanisms.

Differeneces of chain hoists & rope hoist

What is the difference between a chain hoist and a wire rope hoist when both are electrically powered and controlled by a remote pendant? What are the applications where a chain hoist or a wire rope hoist should be used?

Material

A wire rope hoist, as the name implies, employs wire rope (made of wire fibre) as a lifting element, whereas a chain hoist uses chains (metal links joined together).

Technique for lifting

Wire rope is wrapped around a grooved drum as it lifts in wire rope hoists, which means the wire rope follows the spiral groove on the drum and moves left and right as well as up. This isn't a major concern in most scenarios, but it won't work in some situations where precision lifting is essential. The chain is pulled via sprockets and deposited into a chain container by a chain hoist. This mechanism provides the real vertical lift and is best for precision lifting applications.

Price

Wire rope hoists are significantly more expensive than chain hoists. They also require less maintenance, which means that both the upfront and ongoing costs are reduced.

Speed and capacity

Chain hoists are substantially weaker than wire rope hoists. They are typically used for operations weighing more over 10 tons. They also lift considerably more swiftly than chain hoists, so if you need to transport a lot of cargo quickly, a wire rope hoist will suffice. A chain hoist, on the other hand, might be acceptable if your budget is limited, you just need to move a little amount of stuff, or you simply require things moved accurately.

Why Should You Use a Chain Hoist?

In general, a chain hoist is an excellent technique to raise lighter loads. Because the hoist units are small and light, they can be used in a variety of applications. They may be used for a variety of lifting applications and are simple to comprehend and use. In assembly lines and other material handling operations, chain hoists are a fantastic way to replace manual lifting. They are more forgiving of side pulls than wire rope hoists and deliver a full vertical lift. Chain hoists are less expensive to maintain and repair, and they can be employed in a variety of settings.

Consider using an electric chain hoist to meet the following needs:

• Approximately 8-10 hours every day, with 20-30 lifts per hour.
• Motor on time per hour is less than 30 minutes.
• A large majority of lifts are operating at full capacity.
• At no extra charge, you can have a true vertical lift.
• High durability for a modest price.
• Less upkeep is required.

More space for side pulling is required (Side pulling not recommended for any kind of hoists)

Hook mounted chain fall electric hoist
Hook mounted, lug mounted, eye mounted chain fall electric hoists with no trolley up to 32 ton
The horizontal handling of the chain fall electric hoists are in conjunction with the hoist trolleys. The chain fall electric hoists with hooks or lugs can be used as fixed hoists mounted on supporting structures, and the chain fall electric hoists with trolleys can be used as travelling hoists running on suitable overhead girder beams or rails.

Electric trolley chain hoist
Motorized trolley & electric trolley electric chain hoists up to 35 ton
Powered trolleys or motorized hoist trolley may add a little cost but offering a high efficient chain fall electric hoist solution which will be a cost-effective solution for a high volume material handling. Electric chain blocks with motorized trolley may give you a exceptional return.

Maual trolley electric chain hoist
Manual trolley electric chain hoists up to 30 ton
The manual trolley chain fall electric hoist is an economical but effective trolley hoists with the combination of manual trolley and electric chain hoists which will be a cost-effective solution for applications where light duty material handling with frequent vertical lifting but less horizontal movement is required.

Low headroom chain electric hoist up to 35 ton
Low headroom chain fall electric hoists are specially designed for workshop with limited working space. With customized designs, the lifting height of low headroom chain fall electric hoists can up to 130 meters, which will be a cost-effective chain fall electric hoist solution for your applications.

Why choose a wire rope hoist

The biggest loads can be lifted by electric wire rope hoists. When you have long lift heights and huge capacity that require precise positioning, they're an excellent choice. A wire rope hoist may be the best option if the load will be supported for an extended period of time. A wire rope hoist or winch can lift the load and satisfy your operating objectives when you need a hoist rated for severe duty.

Whatever type of hoist you require, it is critical to select the appropriate equipment for the job. Chain hoists are excellent for lifting light weights and can even take the place of physical material handling in your existing operations. Wire rope hoists are the workhorses, capable of handling the heaviest capacities and facilitating the lifting of huge loads. Always keep these considerations in mind when selecting lifting equipment, and consult with professionals as you weigh your alternatives so you can select the best equipment for the job and ensure safe lifting. Do you need assistance with your next project's design? Get in touch with us to find the right lifting solution for you!

Consider using an electric wire rope hoist to meet the following needs:

• Lifting speed can be adjusted if desired.
• More than 30 lifts per hour and more than 30 minutes of motor on time per hour are required.
• Parts like as motors and limit switches are interchangeable and easy to maintain.

Fixed Type Wire Rope Hoist

• Lifting Capacity:0.25t to 50t
• Lifting Height: 3m to 100m
• Lifting Speed: 0.33~8,Single or Dual Speed
• Working Class: M3, M4
• Ambient Temperature: -20℃ to 40℃

Travelling Wire Rope Hoist

• Lifting Capacity:0.25t to 50t
• Lifting Height: 3m to 100m
• Lifting Speed: 0.33~8,Single or Dual Speed
• Working Class: M3, M4
• Ambient Temperature: -20℃ to 40℃

Double girder hoist crane

• Lifting Capacity:0.25t to 60 ton 
• Lifting Height: 3m to 100m
• Lifting Speed: 0.33~8,Single or Dual Speed
• Working Class: M3, M4
• Ambient Temperature: -20℃ to 40℃

Single girder hoist crane

• Lifting Capacity:0.25 ton to 50 ton
• Lifting Height: 3m to 100m
• Lifting Speed: 0.33~8,Single or Dual Speed
• Working Class: M3, M4
• Ambient Temperature: -20℃ to 40℃

Which is best for you

Which is best for you, electric chain hoist.vs. Electric wire rope hoist?

Capacity

Before determining what type of heavy lifting equipment to buy, it's best to assess one's individual heavy lifting needs. The height of the lift, the capacity of the hoist, the budget, the environment, and the application are all important aspects in determining which type of hoist is appropriate for your needs. A poor choice of equipment for your project can lead to unnecessary or premature maintenance, large-scale execution inefficiencies, and a higher total cost of ownership.

To put it another way, an electric chain hoist is ideal for lifting smaller loads. An electric chain hoist has units that are lightweight and small in size, making it suitable for a variety of tasks. They are also simple to learn and operate for operators. Electric chain hoists must be used to replace the manual lifting procedure in assembly lines. These ensure that the lift is truly vertical. They're also a suitable choice for applications that require a low weight yet great lift, such as windmills. Because they are corrosion, wear, and heat resistant, they require minimal maintenance.

An electric wire rope hoist, on the other hand, is better for lifting bigger loads. They're also suitable for lifts with long lift heights and large capacities. If your job demands a bigger load to be hoisted quickly, an electric wire rope hoist is the ideal option. The equipment also facilitates the interchangeability of parts such as motors and limit switches, as well as their maintenance. They are not, however, the best option for a real vertical lift.

Even if you know your capacity, have a well-balanced option between rope and chain hoists, and the prices are comparable, there are other elements that will influence your choice.

Operator education

The choice of hoist system is influenced by hoist operator training. Your employee may be comfortable with one hoisting system, and transferring to a new hoisting system will result in additional training costs and lower output due to inexperience.

Changing the weight of the burden

In other cases, you might want to go from a chain to a wire hoist if you think you'll be handling larger, heavier loads in the future and it's better to prepare now rather than later.

Hoist brand

You can be devoted to a particular brand.

Aside from the factors listed above, there may be other factors that influence your decision to choose a hoist system. We provide a wide selection of chain and rope hoists for you to choose from, as well as free consultation services to assist you in selecting the best hoist for your application.

Conclusion

A plant's lifting equipment is a major investment. So, when deciding between different types of equipment, it's critical to first grasp and analyze the equipment's benefits and drawbacks before making a decision. A substantial amount of money is required to install a hoist. As a result, it's critical to supply all relevant information to the hoist supplier, such as capacity, environment, application, and so on, so that the factory may make an informed decision.

Article by Bella ，who has been in the hoist and crane field since 2016. Bella provides overhead crane & gantry crane consultation services for clients who need a customized overhead travelling crane solution.Contact her to get free consultation.